Were british soldiers lions led donkeys

were british soldiers lions led donkeys Some people hold the view that the british soldiers of the first world war were ‘lions lead by donkeys’ the accusations are that the generals controlled the army with poor leadership with no remorse to the high numbers of deaths and casualties.

History-lions led by donkeys essay sample written by alan clark a politician in the 1960s this quotation describes the leadership of the british military and their strategies used in the great war it suggests that soldiers fighting in the world war were brave and courageous as he refers to them as lions. German general erich freidrich ludendorff called the british soldiers “lions led by donkeys” as taylor reminds us, this description was not confined to the british, or to soldiers he argued “all the peoples were in the same boat. The stereotype saying about the british wwi soldiers is lions led by donkeys the brave soldiers (lions) lead by incompetent generals (donkeys) who lived miles behind the front in luxury and out of touch with reality.

Lions led by donkeys is a phrase popularly used to describe the british infantry of world war i and to condemn the generals who commanded them the contention is that the brave soldiers ( lions ) were sent to their deaths by incompetent and indifferent leaders ( donkeys ) [ 1 . Lions led by donkeys is a phrase popularly used to describe the british infantry of the first world war and to condemn the generals who commanded them the contention is that the brave soldiers ( lions ) were sent to their deaths by incompetent and indifferent leaders ( donkeys . Some 12% of the british army's ordinary soldiers were killed during the war, compared with 17% of its officers eton alone lost more than 1,000 former pupils - 20% of those who served uk wartime prime minister herbert asquith lost a son, while future prime minister andrew bonar law lost two. To say that the viewpoint of incompetent military leaders have both been subject to attempts at revisionism implies that the lions led by donkeys theory is mainstream it is not this notion is itself revisionism, the result on one man's book in the 1960's.

The stereotype is that the ordinary soldiers were lions led by donkeys – the donkeys being incompetent, uncaring generals, responsible for thousands of unnecessary deaths. General ludendorff from the german side was the one who mentioned it he believed that the british were 'lions led by donkeys' as he was impressed with the courage and tenacity of the british soldiers. This is direct criticism against the generals, and evidence that the soldiers were ‘lions led by donkeys’ the commander-in-cheif generals of the british army during the first world war were sir john french (1915) and sir douglas haig (915 onwards. Lions led by donkeys is a phrase popularly used to describe the british infantry of world war i and to blame the generals who led them the contention is that the brave soldiers (lions) w ere sent to their deaths by incompetent and indifferent leaders (donkeys.

My conclusionbritish lions, dutiful british subjects, brilliant and brave young college boys, tough miners, simple honest tradesmen and factory workers were led by donkeys for lack of an even more derogatory term. A description of the british soldiers of wwi what's the origin of the phrase 'lions led by donkeys' it is widely thought that the british infantry of wwi (the lions) were consistently sent to their deaths by their incompetent and out-of-touch generals (the donkeys. The lions were not led by donkeys the first world war was a conflict of gangrene, gas and ghastliness, a futile massacre that achieved nothing in which a whole generation of deluded teenagers were. Lions led by donkeys is a phrase popularly used to describe the british infantry of world war i and to blame the generals who led them the contention is that the brave soldiers ( lions ) were sent to their deaths by incompetent and indifferent leaders ( donkeys ) [1.

Lion led by donkeys essay sample introduction in my essay, i shall be interpret ting why so many people believe “lions led by donkeys” was just idiotic generals leading his own soldiers in to a cold blooded war, which led to thousands of deaths and even more distraught families. Told by the highly impressed quartermaster general ludendorff that “these british soldiers fight like lions,” general max hoffmann had responded: “yes, but lions led by donkeys. ‘lions led by donkeys’ a german army commander once described the british army as ‘lions led by donkeys’ he admired the courage of ordinary british soldiers, but felt that many lives could have been saved had their generals performed their jobs more effectively.

1 lions led by donkeys this is an article by professor peter simkin, challenging the idea that great war generals were incompetent 2 lions led by donkeys this is a similar article to the one above and is by dr gary sheffield, another leading ww1 historian. The expression “lions led by donkeys” means that brave soldiers were instructed and led to their deaths by stupid generals some of these sources support the view that british soldiers in world war one were ‘led by donkeys. Introduction british and american culture 'taking the offensive' were the british soldiers lions led by donkeys essay topics the horses: volunteering were the british soldiers lions led by donkeys essay topics with animals and conservation is an amazing way to travel the world and make a positive impact every ethics in construction industry.

In short, ordinary british and dominion officers were lions led by donkeys images of somme and passchaendale persist the myth of the uncaring general - safely dining and drinking in his chateau while the front-line troops lived and died in squalor - has proved especially durable - and has been reinforced recently by stephen fry's portrayal. Home lions led by donkeys even today, people hold strong opinions about the commanders of the british and allied forces in the great war there is a range of different views: the commanders were 'donkeys' they were incompetent and didn't take care of their soldiers, the 'lions' they sat in safety behind the lines while they sent their. World war one comes under much criticism when it comes to the politics at home and the way in which the war was led this essay will look at how the british government (known as the donkeys in the interpretation) led british soldiers (known as the lions in the interpretation) through the four-year battle with germany. Lions led by donkeys is a phrase popularly used to describe the british infantry of the first world war and to blame the generals who led them the contention is that the brave soldiers ( lions ) were sent to their deaths by incompetent and indifferent leaders ( donkeys ) [1.

were british soldiers lions led donkeys Some people hold the view that the british soldiers of the first world war were ‘lions lead by donkeys’ the accusations are that the generals controlled the army with poor leadership with no remorse to the high numbers of deaths and casualties. were british soldiers lions led donkeys Some people hold the view that the british soldiers of the first world war were ‘lions lead by donkeys’ the accusations are that the generals controlled the army with poor leadership with no remorse to the high numbers of deaths and casualties. were british soldiers lions led donkeys Some people hold the view that the british soldiers of the first world war were ‘lions lead by donkeys’ the accusations are that the generals controlled the army with poor leadership with no remorse to the high numbers of deaths and casualties. were british soldiers lions led donkeys Some people hold the view that the british soldiers of the first world war were ‘lions lead by donkeys’ the accusations are that the generals controlled the army with poor leadership with no remorse to the high numbers of deaths and casualties.
Were british soldiers lions led donkeys
Rated 5/5 based on 21 review

2018.